Friday, September 9, 2022
Carnegie Mellon University in Africa
Sunday, August 7, 2022
Only in Chicago!
A very interesting post for Inside Higher Education included a run-down of a visit to Chicago. It was quite a pleasure to see my current city profiled in such a positive way. Highlights included the Art Institute, Shedd Aquarium, riding the EL, and a Cubs game at Wrigley Stadium. Yes, Chicago is a pretty wondrous place.
Oh, and by the way, Chicago has higher education opportunity across the full spectrum of community colleges to open public and private universities to some of the most recognized brands for quality education in the world.
Wednesday, July 20, 2022
Differentiating students' motivations, services, and cost
An arm-chair view of higher education in the U.S.A. reveals a vast number of institutions trying to emulate each other, especially the more successful institutions judged by competitiveness of admission standards and number enrolled. A framework was laid out for differentiating student motivations and therefore services at a meeting of the National Association of College & University Business Officers. This could be a game-changer in terms of appeal to discrete populations and it could save every institution money - by allowing each to avoid replicating each other by providing resources and services that mean little to some of their students.
The student typologies identified in the model (from most likely to be currently involved in traditional institutions to least likely) are:
- Wayfinding intellectuals (7%)
- Campus enthusiasts (16%)
- Junior specialists (31%)
- Evolving professionals (23%)
- Mid-career climbers (14%)
- Trajectory performers (9)
Monday, July 18, 2022
Courting international students requires new mind-set
In a statement calling for a new mind-set toward Chinese international students in the U.S.A., Xiafeng Wan asserted, "The prevalent mind-set of treating Chinese students as cash cows is not only detrimental to U.S. higher education's reputation for academic excellence and quality but also dehumanizes Chinese students and diminishes their innumerable intellectual and social contributions to their host institutions and U.S. society."
Proof of the economic motivations to attract international students is reflected in many places and particularly in the post-pandemic rebound of international students. While they still represent the largest contingent, the rebound includes a sustained drop in Chinese student enrollment. One of the important elements to consider in working with Chinese students is family and their ability to pay. Stereotypes of Chinese students are that they are all wealthy. While many can pay, or sacrifice to pay, there is considerable variation which must be understood if Chinese families are to continue to fund the enormous amounts of money required for U.S.A. degrees.
Richard J. Joseph in his book, Bridging the Gap Between the Abundance of American Higher Education Talent and the Immense Foreign Demand for it, looks at the necessity of U.S.A. institutions to pay attention to the financial bottom line but urged educators to go further. In addition to the financial implications, Joseph recommended remaining true to the altruistic calling of education as a transformative experience and enhancing sustainability while advancing knowledge diplomacy. While these aims are central, it is important not to perpetuate cultural imperialism but, "strive to strengthen a liberal world order in which men and women can pursue the truth freely, without fear and based on their own cultural values."
Joseph's book, although not focused on the humanities, complements a view that the humanities should embrace international perspectives. In fact, internationalizing may be the path to survival of majors beyond the service courses offered by humanities programs. Advocating more in international perspective is not only strategic for survival but is an important element to "help institutions maximize the effectiveness of exceptionally diverse workforces" and prepare graduates to embrace "the anxieties that many individuals feel in environments without well-defined norms, expectations and pathways to advancement."
Franklin & Marshall was unusually successful in maintaining robust enrollment of international students even during the political gyrations of the Trump years and then the pandemic. Shifting to a Shanghai in-person location and on-line learning helped, which complemented the personal touch of a faculty member who was a strong internationalization advocate. F&M President, Barbara K. Altman, attributes their success to fully meeting student need, whether foreign or domestic, and creating a global community from which all students can benefit.
Friday, July 15, 2022
What employers want is not far from what educators cultivate
The ambivalence among many U.S.A. academics about career preparation lingers in many institutions and intellectual circles. The practicality of what students seek, which is a job at the end of the degree, and what employers value in skills for their employees may be more similar than some think. It's practical and economic on everyone's part - students, institutions, and those who hire graduates.
Research on the AAC&U's essential learning outcomes found that what employers uniformly want are critical thinking skills. Line managers versus executives were aligned on some skills and slightly different on others. Critical thinking, inquiry and analysis, problem solving, teamwork, and written communication were top-ranked by both groups. Creative thinking and oral communication were identified as more important among managers while ethical reasoning and integrative learning were ranked higher for executives. Presidents of liberal arts institutions engaged with technology sector leaders in discussion about the balance between skill-based training and generalizable learning outcomes. The conclusion was that both are valued and that liberal arts leaders will be best served to focus on, and more actively promote, the benefits of the learning outcomes previously characterized as "soft skills," which are increasingly being seen as "people" or "power" skills. A confession of a liberal arts faculty member who found that liberal education does not stand in opposition to career interests reinforces this point.
While self-awareness is not on the AAC&U essential learning outcomes list, it isn't difficult to determine that it is foundational to skills such as problem solving and teamwork. It's very difficult to engage in critical thinking and analysis in a group if you're unaware of who you are and how you impact others. With notable public figures lacking and being unaware of themselves, some would say that technical preparation or skills are much more trainable than temperament.
Equally important to understand are what skills employers ranked lowest from the essential learning outcomes. Lifelong learning, global learning, and intercultural knowledge and competence made this list but that's not because they are unimportant. Employers view these skills as being developed during employment as recent graduates mature in their worklife.
An adjoining and critical question is the degree to which work-readiness is actually occurring. It's one thing to align institutional goals and student desires but, if work preparedness is not achieved, everyone suffers. Inside Higher Education's Student Voice survey identified a significant lack of experiential learning to support work-readiness. "Nearly four in 10 (39 percent) college students and recent graduates surveyed have had neither an internship nor an experiential learning opportunity this past year."
Educators will benefit from attending to what employers seek in graduates; from this research, alignment is not far off. However, employers believe that critical thinking and written communication skills are the most consistently needed attributes and are sometimes not as well developed as they would prefer.
Friday, June 10, 2022
Gun violence
Friday, June 3, 2022
Influence flows with money in international higher education
Citing the "revolving door" of those moving around academia and politics, think-tanks and various industries, the Biden administration's U.S. Department of Education continues to refine policy and track gifts from foreign entities to higher education and by May of 2023 chose to maintain previous requirements. The Bipartisan Innovation Act "is meant to boost America's competitiveness in the global economy, but also includes language that would beef up foreign donation transparency laws." Individuals and institutions receiving donations of more than $50,000 will have to report these gifts.
The House Education Committee proposed to reduce the foreign gift threshold from $250,000 to $50,000. The proposed DETERRENT Act would also require reporting of gifts to faculty and staff as well as report foreign investments in endowments exceeding $6 billion. The House Committee approved the overhaul of gift reporting with its chair, Virginia Foxx, saying it would "help address declining public confidence in American universities."
The legal requirement to report gifts goes back to 1986 but widespread failure in reporting was alleged during the DeVos years as Secretary of Education. Fear of the influence of China's Confucius Institutes drove some of the concern about foreign gifts. But the reality is that many countries offer gifts to individuals and institutions that go beyond sharing ideas to improve educational practice and impact. Doug White, a philanthropy scholar, warned "There is a national interest to be sure that money coming from foreign sources doesn't infiltrate power policy making in the United States. The origin of the money and how it was spent - these things need to be known to the public, not just internally."
The Director of the FBI defended its probe of Chinese influence in U.S.A. higher education. A Bill was also introduced in the U.S.A. Congress to encourage major universities to withdraw endowment investments in China. These actions are based on the assumption that Chinese investments would support China's advancement in the world scientific and economic systems.
The new wrinkle is that a Department of Defense sponsored report has now opened a path to approving Confucius Institutes again. The former Director of the Confucius Institutes U.S. Center responded by saying, "If we really want to cooperate with China, if people can work together to change their countries, we need those people-to-people programs. This report may build momentum for academic institutions to take a leading role and to be resilient in continuing to work on those peope-to-people programs." Approval to host Institutes requires a waiver approval.